Kitchen Tips & How-Tos

Forgot to Take the Butter Out? 3 Ways to Soften It Fast

Grating cold butter

I wanted to bake cookies with my granddaughter and realized the butter was rock hard in the fridge. She was ready to wait an hour. Here’s how we had it ready in minutes.

Grating cold butter

1. Grate It

Use a cheese grater on cold butter. The thin shreds soften in just a few minutes.

2. Cut It Into Cubes

Small cubes soften much faster than a whole stick. Spread them out on a plate.

3. The Warm Glass Trick

Fill a glass with hot water for a minute, pour the water out and dry it. Turn the warm glass upside down over the stick of butter. In a few minutes, the butter softens without melting.

The warm glass butter trick

Why Not the Microwave?

The microwave melts butter unevenly, often leaving a puddle in the middle and a hard stick around it. Melted butter changes how cookies and cakes turn out. If you do use it, try very short bursts of a few seconds.

How to Tell It’s Ready

Press it with your finger. Softened butter leaves a dent but doesn’t feel greasy or look shiny.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why does softened butter matter?

It mixes with sugar to trap air, which makes cakes and cookies light.

Can I leave butter out every day?

Many people keep a small amount in a covered butter dish for a day or two.

No more waiting an hour for butter.

Try It Tonight

Two free cookbooks: 30 Easy Slow Cooker Beef Recipes and 25 Five-Ingredient Slow Cooker Dinners

2 free cookbooks · 55 recipes

2 Free Slow Cooker Cookbooks

55 comforting dinners across 132 pages — the beef collection and the five-ingredient one, both yours.

By submitting, you agree to receive emails from It’s Not About Nutrition. Unsubscribe anytime.