Save This Recipe
We'll email this post to you, so you can come back to it later!
When Tomatoes are in season and the counter is overflowing with them, this is the snack I make on repeat. Three ingredients, no cooking, no real skill required — just crackers, cream cheese, and the ripest tomatoes you can get your hands on. It’s the kind of simple that somehow still gets people asking for the “recipe,” even though there isn’t much of one to give.
Why You’ll Love It
Ready in 10 minutes— no oven, no cooking, just assembly
Only 3 ingredients — crackers, cream cheese, tomatoes, nothing fancy required
Always a crowd-pleaser — even people who claim they don’t like tomatoes go back for more
Pantry-friendly — you probably already have two of the three ingredients on hand
Looks more impressive than it is — a plate of these reads as “effort” with almost none required
A Few Thoughts on the Ingredients
The crackers — I use the buttery round ones, the classic ones, whatever’s on sale honestly, though my sister swears the name-brand ones hold up better and don’t go soggy as fast. She might be right. I’ve never done a side-by-side because that feels like more effort than the recipe deserves.
Cream cheese needs to be soft, actually soft, not the kind you pull out of the fridge and try to spread five minutes later while it fights you the whole way and tears the cracker. I usually just leave it on the counter while I’m doing something else — folding laundry, yelling at somebody to find their shoes — and by the time I come back it’s ready.
And the tomatoes. This is the one ingredient where I’ll be a little bit particular. Grocery store tomatoes in January are basically red water balloons, no offense to grocery stores, they’re doing their best with what they’ve got in the off season. But if you can get your hands on tomatoes that actually grew somewhere nearby and got to sit in the sun and do their thing — that’s where this recipe stops being “fine” and starts being something people ask you about.
What You’ll Need
– 24 buttery round crackers (give or take — depends how heavy-handed you are with the toppings, I always end up with a few extra crackers left in the sleeve)
– 4 ounces cream cheese, softened
– 2 medium ripe tomatoes, sliced into thin rounds — thin is relative, don’t stress over it
How to Put Them Together
Wash your tomatoes, dry them well — and I mean actually pat them down, because tomatoes hold onto water like they’re being paid to. Slice them into thin rounds. If you cut into one and juice just comes pouring out, go ahead and blot the slices with a paper towel for a second. I skipped this step once for a bridal shower tray and by the time people got to the third row of crackers they were basically mush. Learned that one the hard way, in front of people.
Take your softened cream cheese and spread a little onto each cracker — I usually just use a butter knife, nothing fancy, though my daughter likes to pipe it on with a bag when she’s feeling ambitious, which is maybe twice a year.
Lay a tomato slice on top of each one, press down just barely so it doesn’t slide off the second somebody picks it up. Don’t press hard — you’ll just push the cream cheese out the sides and then you’ve got a mess.
Arrange them on a plate — I like a big platter so they’re not all crowded together — and serve them right away. This isn’t a make-ahead-and-let-it-sit situation. The clock is sort of ticking the moment you put tomato on cracker.
Ways People Change It Up
My sister-in-law adds a little salt and pepper on top, which I never think to do and then always regret not doing. My daughter goes rogue and uses the chive cream cheese, sometimes the vegetable one, and honestly those versions might be better than mine, I try not to think about it too hard. Somebody at a work lunch once brought a version with a tiny basil leaf tucked under the tomato and it was — fine, I guess, a little too pretty for what this recipe is supposed to be, in my opinion. I tried a whipped cream cheese one time thinking it’d spread easier and it just slid right off the cracker the second anyone tilted the plate. Learned that one the hard way too, apparently I learn most things the hard way.
If you’re doing a big batch for a crowd, don’t try to assemble ahead — set it up like a little assembly line instead, crackers here, cream cheese there, tomatoes on the end, and let people do the last step themselves, or do it right as folks are walking in the door. Works better than you’d think.
Leftovers, Sort Of
There really isn’t a leftover situation with these, in my experience — they get eaten. But if you do end up with extra, the components keep separately just fine. Sliced tomatoes in the fridge for a day, maybe, though they’ll weep a little more moisture than you’d like. Cream cheese obviously keeps. Crackers keep forever, they’re crackers. What you should not do is assemble a bunch and put them in the fridge overnight thinking you’ll get a jump on things — I did that once for a holiday and pulled out a tray of what I can only describe as cracker soup the next morning. Wasn’t pretty.