Save This Recipe
We'll email this post to you, so you can come back to it later!
These brown sugar bacon crackers are the three-ingredient appetizer that looks like it took all afternoon — and disappears in about eight minutes flat. Salty, sticky, and just sweet enough, they’re made with Buttery crackers, thick-cut bacon, and brown sugar, and the oven does all the work.
Why You’ll Love Them
Only 3 ingredients — crackers, bacon, and brown sugar, nothing else needed
Practically hands-off — the oven does all the work while you get everything else ready
Salty-sweet in the best way — the bacon gets almost lacquered by the caramelized sugar, and the cracker underneath absorbs the drippings in a way that just works
Crowd-proof — these disappear faster than anything fancier you could bring; no leftovers, ever
Easy to make ahead — cool completely, refrigerate, and reheat in a low oven before serving
A Note About the Ingredients
The crackers: they need to be buttery and rectangular. The club-style ones in the red box are what I use. I’ve tried the off-brand versions and they’re fine, mostly, though once I got a bag that was slightly stale before I opened it and the whole batch tasted sad. Worth buying fresh.
The bacon: thick-cut. This is not negotiable in my kitchen. Thin bacon just kind of shrivels and disappears and you lose the whole point, which is a proper strip of meat caramelized into something wonderful. I like a good smoky one — the brand doesn’t matter so much as the thickness and the smoke level.
The brown sugar: light brown, packed. I’ve used dark brown in a pinch and it’s a little more molasses-forward, which is fine, it just tastes slightly different. Not worse, just different. I always keep light brown on hand so I use that.
Ingredients
18 to 24 buttery rectangular crackers (I usually just do a full sleeve)
8 to 10 slices thick-cut bacon, cut into pieces to fit — halves or thirds, depending on your crackers
About 3/4 cup packed light brown sugar, maybe a little more if I’m feeling generous
How to Make Them
Preheat your oven to 275°F. That low temperature is the whole point — don’t rush it.
Line a rimmed baking sheet with foil. Don’t skip this. The sugar bubbles up and runs and if you’re cleaning it off an unlined pan you will be annoyed with me, and you’ll have a right to be. I let the foil come up the sides a bit so nothing escapes.
Lay your crackers in a single layer, touching but not overlapping. Then put a piece of bacon on each one — just set it right on top, it doesn’t have to be perfect. Then spoon brown sugar over each one, press it down a little so it sticks to the bacon, and that’s the whole assembly. I go kind of heavy on the sugar. That’s just who I am.
Slide them into the oven, middle rack, and let them go for somewhere between forty and sixty minutes. My oven runs a little hot so I usually check around thirty-five minutes, but most people will hit their sweet spot closer to fifty. You’re looking for bacon that’s cooked through and a sugar situation that looks glossy and slightly syrupy. The crackers should be a deep golden color. You’ll know when it’s right.
Let them sit on the foil for ten, maybe fifteen minutes after they come out. The sugar is molten at first — I burned my finger once being impatient, which I fully deserved — and it needs time to set up into that clingy, sticky glaze that holds everything together. Then loosen them gently with a thin spatula. They’ll come up cleanly if you give them enough time to cool.
I put them on a fresh sheet of foil on a platter. They look good that way and the foil catches any stray bits of sugar.
Variations
Adding a pinch of cayenne to the brown sugar before sprinkling changes the whole personality of the dish without technically adding an ingredient to the tray. That version is worth trying — maybe even more than the original.
I tried making them once with honey instead of brown sugar and the less said about that the better. It pooled off the crackers and burned on the foil and the smoke alarm went off. That was years ago. I haven’t experimented since.
Storage
If you have any left — and I’m serious, this is a real if — let them cool all the way, then layer them between parchment in a container and refrigerate. They’re fine for a couple of days. I reheat them in a low oven, around 250°F, just long enough to re-crisp and warm the sugar back up. Don’t microwave them. Trust me.
Don’t leave them out longer than a couple hours, especially if it’s warm. Which, at this time of year, it usually is.