Save This Recipe
We'll email this post to you, so you can come back to it later!
This Slow Cooker 4-ingredient Amish Chicken Pot Pie is warm, savory, and wonderfully easy, with tender chicken, Potatoes, and broad noodles in a creamy broth. Start the chicken, potatoes, and broth in the slow cooker, then add the noodles at the end for a cozy, filling bowl that lands somewhere between chicken noodle soup and Baked pot pie. You’re going to love this simple comfort-food dinner.
Why You’ll Love It
- Four main ingredients — chicken, potatoes, broth, and wide noodles make a complete, hearty dinner.
- No browning or roux — the slow cooker does the work with minimal prep.
- Tender chicken and creamy broth — the chicken shreds easily, while the potatoes and noodles thicken the broth as they cook.
- Comforting and filling — serve it with green beans, a sharp little salad, or bread for a proper supper.
- Makes generous portions — enough for six people, or four people plus leftovers for lunch tomorrow.
Ingredient Notes
Boneless, skinless chicken thighs are my preference because they stay tender and forgiving. Breasts work perfectly well, though, especially if that’s what you have in the freezer section of your brain when you’re standing at the grocery store staring blankly at the meat case. Just thaw them in the refrigerator first—don’t put frozen chicken straight into the slow cooker. I know people do it. I’m not here to scold, but I am here to say don’t.
Use low-sodium chicken broth if you can. The noodles soak up a surprising amount of flavor and salt, and it’s easier to add a little seasoning at the end than to undo an over-salted pot.
Russet potatoes make the broth a little starchier and heartier. Yukon Golds hold their shape nicely and have that buttery flavor even though there isn’t any butter in this recipe. Either one is fine. I lean Yukon when they look decent at the store.
For the noodles, look for wide Amish-style egg noodles or pot pie noodles. If you live somewhere they’re hard to find, use the widest egg noodles you can get and watch them closely. Regular egg noodles cook faster, and mushy noodles are one of life’s little insults.
Ingredients
- 2 pounds boneless, skinless chicken thighs or chicken breasts—I usually buy thighs, but breasts are just fine
- 4 cups low-sodium chicken broth
- 3 large russet or Yukon Gold potatoes, peeled and cut into 1-inch chunks, about 1 1/2 pounds
- 12 ounces wide Amish-style egg noodles or pot pie noodles, the thick square or broad kind if you can find them
- Salt and black pepper, optional, added at the end to taste
- A little hot water or extra warm broth, only if the finished pot gets thicker than you like
Instructions
Put the peeled, chopped potatoes in an even layer across the bottom of a 5- to 7-quart slow cooker. Keep the pieces close to 1 inch if you can. I am not out here measuring every potato cube with a ruler, but if some are tiny and some are the size of a deck of cards, you’ll get uneven results and then we all have regrets.
Lay the chicken on top of the potatoes in a single layer as best you can. There’s no need to cut it up first—thank goodness. It will shred later without much fuss. If you’re using a mix of thighs and breasts, spread them around evenly so one kind isn’t piled on top of the other.
Pour the chicken broth over everything. The broth should mostly cover the chicken and potatoes. If your slow cooker is one of those broad, shallow ones and the top of the chicken is sticking out a bit, add just enough water or extra broth to barely submerge it. Not a whole lake. Just enough.
Cover and cook on LOW for 6 to 7 hours or on HIGH for 3 to 4 hours, until the chicken is fully cooked, very tender, and easy to shred, and the potatoes give easily when pierced with a knife. Try not to lift the lid every half hour. Slow cookers lose heat fast when you do that, and then dinner turns into “why aren’t we eating until eight?”
Use tongs to move the cooked chicken to a large plate or cutting board. Shred it with two forks into bite-sized pieces, discarding any visible fat as you go. Make sure the chicken reaches 165°F in the center before shredding. Return all the shredded chicken—and any juices that collected on the plate—back to the slow cooker.
Stir the chicken, potatoes, and broth gently so everything is distributed around the pot. Add the wide noodles, then press them down with a spoon so most of them are sitting in the hot liquid. They may look like they’re crowding things at first. They settle down.
Cover again and cook on HIGH for 20 to 35 minutes, stirring once or twice if you can, until the noodles are tender but not falling apart. The exact timing depends on the noodle brand and your slow cooker. Start checking around 20 minutes, especially if you had to use ordinary wide egg noodles instead of true pot pie noodles.
Stir the finished pot well. The potatoes and noodles will release starch and make the broth creamy and thick, which is exactly what you want. If it gets thicker than a stew you’d happily eat from a bowl, stir in a splash of hot water or warm chicken broth until it loosens up.
Taste and add salt and black pepper if you think it needs it, then ladle into warm bowls with plenty of broth, chicken, potatoes, and noodles in each serving. Serve it while it’s steaming. This is not one of those foods that improves while sitting around posing for photographs.
Variations
If you want to keep the four-ingredient spirit, leave it just as it is. That’s honestly my favorite way. Frozen peas and diced carrots can be stirred in during the last 10 minutes with the noodles. It gives the bowls a little color and makes the dish feel more “complete.”
For a creamier finish, you can stir in 1/2 to 1 cup whole milk or half-and-half at the very end and let it warm gently. Don’t boil it hard after adding dairy. I tried a version once with a can of cream soup, thinking I was being clever, and it was fine—fine!—but it tasted less like the simple farmhouse-style bowl I wanted. Too thick, too processed, too much going on. Sometimes a recipe doesn’t need improving. Sometimes it needs us to quit fiddling with it.
You can also use bone-in split chicken breasts and thighs for a more old-fashioned flavor, but remove the skin first and be very careful to discard every bone when you shred the meat. I only do that when I have the energy.
Storage & Reheating
Cool leftovers promptly and get them into the refrigerator within 2 hours. They’ll keep well for 3 to 4 days, though the noodles will continue soaking up broth as they sit. By the next day, it can look almost like a Casserole in the container. Don’t panic—it still tastes good.
Reheat it gently on the stovetop over low to medium heat, adding a splash of broth or water as needed. The microwave works too, especially for lunch, but cover the bowl loosely unless you enjoy wiping chicken broth off the inside of the microwave door. I once found a dried noodle stuck up near the light bulb in ours. No idea how it got there. Physics has failed me.
I don’t love freezing this one after the noodles are cooked because they get soft and a little sad upon thawing. You can freeze the chicken-potato-broth portion before adding noodles, then cook fresh noodles when you reheat it, but that is a level of planning I rarely achieve.
Final Notes
There’s something about a dinner like this that quiets a room down. Not in a magical way—there can still be arguments over whose turn it is to unload the dishwasher while holding bowls in their laps—but for a few minutes, anyway, everything settles in.
It has the same idea behind it: tender chicken, soft potatoes, noodles in a golden broth, enough warmth to make a worn-out person feel looked after.
That counts for quite a bit. Especially on the days when nobody has much left to give.
Slow Cooker 4-Ingredient Amish Chicken Pot Pie
Ingredients
- 2 pounds boneless, skinless chicken thighs or chicken breasts Thaw in the refrigerator first; do not use frozen chicken.
- 4 cups low-sodium chicken broth
- 3 large russet or Yukon Gold potatoes Peeled and cut into 1-inch chunks, about 1 1/2 pounds.
- 12 ounces wide Amish-style egg noodles or pot pie noodles Use the thick square or broad kind if available.
- to taste salt and black pepper Add at the end if needed.
- as needed hot water or extra warm chicken broth Use only if the finished pot is thicker than desired.
Instructions
- Put the peeled, chopped potatoes in an even layer across the bottom of a 5- to 7-quart slow cooker, keeping the pieces close to 1 inch.
- Lay the chicken on top of the potatoes in a single layer as best you can.
- Pour the chicken broth over everything; if the chicken is not mostly submerged, add just enough water or extra broth to barely cover it.
- Cover and cook on LOW for 6 to 7 hours or on HIGH for 3 to 4 hours, until the chicken is fully cooked and tender and the potatoes are easily pierced with a knife.
- Use tongs to transfer the cooked chicken to a plate or cutting board, shred it into bite-sized pieces with two forks, discard visible fat, and confirm that it reaches 165°F in the center before shredding.
- Return the shredded chicken and any juices to the slow cooker, stir gently, add the wide noodles, and press them down so most are sitting in the hot liquid.
- Cover and cook on HIGH for 20 to 35 minutes, stirring once or twice if possible, until the noodles are tender but not falling apart.
- Stir the finished pot well, then add a splash of hot water or warm chicken broth if the starch from the potatoes and noodles has made it thicker than desired.
- Taste and add salt and black pepper if needed, then ladle the steaming chicken, potatoes, noodles, and broth into warm bowls.