Save This Recipe
We'll email this post to you, so you can come back to it later!
When the holidays start creeping up on us—and honestly, doesn’t it feel like you blink and suddenly there are pumpkins and turkeys everywhere?—there’s one side dish that never fails to get my family speaking up: stuffing. Or is it dressing? Depends on who you’re asking, and trust me, that argument can get livelier than a family board game night (but that’s a whole other story for another time).
Whether you’re serving it alongside the Thanksgiving turkey or a cozy Sunday evening roast, stuffing always seems to spark a little nostalgia—and maybe a tiny bit of opinionated chatter. But here’s the big question on everyone’s mind: do you pop open a box of Stove Top, or do you get a little flour-dusted making it from scratch?
I know folks who turn up their noses at anything but from-scratch—homemade bread cubes, fresh herbs, and all that jazz. Then there are those (myself included some years!) who swear by the “open box, add butter, done” method. Both sides have their reasons, and let’s be honest, in this house, we’ve tried them all over the years.
Let’s pull up a chair and have a heart-to-heart about the pros, cons, and those little real-life factors that’ll help you pick the perfect stuffing for your table this year.
The Case for Stove Top: Sometimes the Box Has Your Back
1. It’s Ridiculously Easy (and Honestly, That’s a Gift)
Look, we’re not all starring in a holiday cooking marathon over here. Most years, I’m juggling way too many pans, last-minute grocery dashes, a houseful of relatives, and the odd kitchen fail (one year I actually forgot to thaw the turkey—ask me how I know). When things get wild, Stove Top stuffing is a real lifesaver.
Here’s the deal: you boil a little water, toss in some butter, stir in the mix, fluff, and you’re done in five minutes flat. It’s basically the culinary equivalent of a helping hand from your neighbor down the street. When you’ve got four other sides on the stove and you’re praying your pie doesn’t turn into soup, boxed stuffing is the friend you didn’t know you needed.
2. Predictable Taste (and Sometimes That’s Just What We Want)
Let’s talk comfort. There’s something to be said about a dish that tastes exactly like you remember—no surprises, just soft, savory, buttery goodness. So many of us grew up with Stove Top on our holiday tables. Maybe it isn’t fancy, but it’s wrapped up in warm fuzzy memories, like the worn-out blanket you keep for chilly evenings.
And honestly, sometimes that feeling—salty, simple, familiar—is just what we need in the middle of the holiday hustle and bustle.
3. Long Shelf Life = A Pantry Hero
Can I let you in on a little secret? I keep a box tucked behind the pasta for food emergencies (those who know—know). Even when it’s not Thanksgiving, that box is ready to rescue a plain rotisserie chicken, add a little oomph to a weeknight meal, or serve as the backbone to a “clean out the fridge” Sunday supper.
There’s no fuss—no chopping or drying or prepping. It just sits there quietly, waiting to swoop in and save dinner when you’re out of ideas and patience.
The Case for Homemade: Stuffing With Soul
1. Flavor Freedom: You Call the Shots
Oh, let’s talk about the joys of homemade stuffing! When you make it yourself, you’re the boss. Sourdough cubes soaked in turkey drippings, caramelized onions, crispy pancetta? Go for it. Feeling southern? Try cornbread, rosemary, maybe some apples. (One year I even tossed in chopped figs and pecans. Talk about a happy accident!)
Homemade stuffing is your kitchen canvas. Add anything that tickles your fancy—herbs, garlic, sausage, cranberries, nuts. It’s all about your family’s favorites, old traditions, or whatever looks good in the produce aisle that week.
2. Texture, Texture, Texture
Texture matters, folks. Maybe you like stuffing soft and almost custardy, or maybe you love the crispy, golden edges with just a hint of crunch (my family’s divided, so I make both—yep, I’m a peacekeeper).
With homemade, you get to pick. Want crusty? Bake it a little longer uncovered. Want it moist? Pour on a touch more broth and tuck it under foil. It’s like picking out the perfect pair of slippers—soft or structured, the choice is all yours.
3. You Know What’s in It (And What’s Not)
This one’s close to my heart. With allergies and dietary preferences cropping up more and more (hello, gluten free kids and vegan cousins!), I like knowing exactly what’s going onto every plate.
Making it from scratch means you’re in control—no mystery “seasoning blends” or preservatives. You can adjust for food allergies, special diets, or just plain peace of mind. Homemade stuffing is as flexible as you need it to be without losing any of that homey goodness.
So… Which Stuffing Deserves the Spotlight?
Brace yourself—there’s no clear winner here, and that’s just the way I like it.
Let’s be honest, not every holiday dinner looks like those glossy magazine photos. Sometimes you’re running on empty, or the crew around the table has more food quirks than you can count. And sometimes, all you want is the comfort of what you know—no frills, no fuss, just that taste of childhood and “togetherness” on your fork.
If reaching for a box of stuffing gives you one less thing to fret about, then by all means, do it. And if you want to go the homemade route, especially when you’ve got a little extra time or that dog-eared recipe from your grandma, don’t hold back—it’s likely to be the star of the spread.
Think about:
-
Your schedule: Are you on cooking duty for the whole crew or just popping by a potluck with a single dish?
-
Your crowd: Is your family full of traditionalists (they want what they grew up with) or more adventurous types looking for something new?
-
Your bandwidth: Seriously—how much energy do you actually have left at this point in the season? (Spoiler: some years my answer is “none whatsoever.”)
Here’s a little trick from my house to yours: You don’t have to pick just one. Put out both! Who says you can’t have a little bit of each? It’s not breaking the rules, it’s making everyone feel at home—and that’s the real win.
A Side Note on Stuffing Safety (Because Aunt Linda Asked)
Quick PSA—because I can practically hear my sister’s voice in my head: if you’re putting stuffing in your turkey, not just in a casserole dish, make sure the middle hits 165°F. Otherwise, you’re flirting with food safety woes—nobody wants a side of trouble at the holiday table. Don’t risk it!
Stuffing Through the Seasons
Stuffing isn’t just a holiday treat in this house. Oh no. I’ve tossed stuffing into baked chicken casseroles and even paired it with pork chops on a chilly March evening. Get creative year-round! Use leftover challah or brioche, or jazz things up with chorizo and roasted poblanos for a fun twist. The sky’s the limit—don’t save all the comfort for November!
Once you stop thinking of stuffing as a “once-a-year” thing, I promise it’ll become one of your favorite little kitchen shortcuts that make any meal feel special.
Final Thoughts: More Than Just Bread and Broth
At the end of the day, stuffing is about so much more than breadcrumbs or box mix. It’s tradition, it’s a memory, it’s comfort served up family-style. Whether you’re serving Stove Top with a wink across the table or passing around your “secret” homemade recipe, what matters most is the care that goes into every spoonful.
Gather your people, say grace, tell old stories—just cherish the moment. Because whether your stuffing comes from a box or your backyard herb garden, it’s meant to fill your belly and your heart with a little something special.
And really, isn’t that the whole point of the season?
