Save This Recipe
We'll email this post to you, so you can come back to it later!
You know that feeling when you open the front door on a cold evening, and the smell of something sweet hits you before you even hang up your coat? That’s rice pudding for you. Simple, warm, familiar — like someone threw a blanket around your shoulders and handed you a spoon.
I’ll admit it: rice pudding doesn’t always win points for glamour. It’s not flashy like lava cakes or trendy like tiramisu. But honestly? It doesn’t need to be. Sometimes the old favorites are exactly what you’re craving.
Five Ingredients, Zero Stress
Here’s what I love about this Slow Cooker Rice Pudding — besides the fact that it tastes like a hug. It’s five ingredients. Just five. And they’re probably hanging out in your kitchen right now, waiting for their moment to shine:
-
Plain old white rice
-
Milk (whole, 2%, oat — whatever you’ve got)
-
Sugar
-
Vanilla extract
-
Ground cinnamon
No eggs, no fancy whisking, no standing at the stove for an hour wondering if you’re scorching the bottom of the pot. Nope. You just set it up, check on it a couple of times, and wait for your house to smell like cozy Sunday afternoons.
The Little Slow Cooker That Could
Now, let’s talk about the real hero here: the slow cooker. Some folks think they’re just for soups and stews that simmer for days. But they’re perfect for gentle desserts too. Rice pudding needs patience and steady warmth — and the slow cooker’s got that in spades.
It’s kind of like having a patient grandma in appliance form. No rush, no fuss, no burnt milk panic at 9 PM. Just a creamy bowl of sweet nostalgia when you want it.
How It Happens — No Fuss, Promise
Alright, so here’s the game plan:
-
Grab a cup of white rice. Give it a good rinse under cold water. I know — rinsing rice always feels like an extra step. But trust me, you want your pudding silky, not gummy.
-
Toss that rice into your slow cooker. Add four cups of milk, half a cup of sugar, a teaspoon of vanilla, and half a teaspoon of cinnamon.
-
Stir it up. Put the lid on. Set it to low.
-
Now go live your life. Do laundry, walk the dog, watch that show you keep saying you’ll start. Just pop in every now and then to give it a gentle stir so nothing sticks too much.
-
After about 4–5 hours, check it — the rice should be tender, and everything should look creamy and delicious. If it’s a bit too thick for your liking, stir in a splash more milk.
And that’s it. No big finale. No fancy garnish required (unless you want it, of course).
Make It Your Own — Grandma Would Approve
This is one of those recipes that loves a little twist.
-
If dairy’s not your jam, use almond milk or coconut milk — they add a subtle nutty or tropical note that’s actually pretty great.
-
Got a bag of raisins gathering dust in the pantry? Toss a handful in before cooking — they’ll plump up and get all sweet and juicy.
-
Feeling extra cozy? Sprinkle in a pinch of nutmeg or cardamom.
-
Sweet tooth still not satisfied? A drizzle of honey or caramel right before serving is dangerously good.
Serving Ideas for Maximum Cozy
The best way to eat rice pudding? Warm, in a big bowl, while you’re wearing fuzzy socks — that’s my vote, anyway.
But if you want to fancy it up, you can:
-
A dollop of whipped cream turns it into dessert-dessert.
-
Vanilla ice cream on top? Melty, creamy goodness.
-
Toasted nuts — almonds, walnuts, pecans — add the perfect crunch.
Pair it with a mug of tea or that second cup of coffee you were trying not to have — no judgment here.
Sweet Little Reminder
It’s easy to forget that sometimes the best things are the simple ones. The old standbys. The recipes that don’t send you to three grocery stores or leave you with a sink full of dishes.
This rice pudding is exactly that — the kind of sweet treat that feels homemade, even if you barely did anything to make it happen. And maybe that’s why I love it so much. It’s low effort, high comfort. No big show. Just warm, familiar goodness that tastes like home.
So the next time you want something sweet without pulling out the fancy gear, remember this one. Rinse some rice. Pour in some milk. Let the slow cooker do its thing. Then sit down, spoon in hand, and enjoy every last creamy bite.
Because sometimes the best desserts aren’t about impressing anyone — they’re just about making you smile at the end of a long day.