Save This Recipe
We'll email this post to you, so you can come back to it later!
There’s something about the smell of lemon and butter mingling in the air that instantly brings me back to Grandma’s kitchen on a chilly Sunday afternoon.
She wasn’t the type to fuss over food. Everything had a rhythm. The potatoes were always peeled before church, the bread was warming in the oven by four, and the fish? Well, the fish practically cooked itself—tucked into the slow cooker while she caught up on her stories and hollered at Grandpa to set the table. That’s the kind of cooking I grew up with—easygoing, full of flavor, and built on the backbone of Midwest traditions.
This Slow Cooker Lemon Butter Cod is my little love letter to those days. It’s clean, comforting, and impossibly tender, swimming in a lemony, garlicky butter sauce that’s just begging for some crusty bread or mashed potatoes to soak it up.
You don’t need anything fancy—just good fish, fresh lemons, and a slow cooker willing to do the work while you do, well, life.
Why This Dish Just Works
-
Low-maintenance, high reward – Just layer, pour, and forget about it for a couple hours.
-
Bright but cozy – The lemon wakes everything up while the butter keeps it grounded and rich.
-
Kid-approved, grown-up loved – Mild cod and smooth sauce? Even the picky eaters come back for seconds.
-
Weeknight saver – You can prep this in under 10 minutes, then let it go while you fold laundry, answer emails, or sneak in an episode of something.
What You’ll Need (And What You Can Swap)
Let’s talk ingredients—but casual, like a neighbor leaning over the fence with her coffee cup.
-
Cod fillets (4) – Fresh or thawed-from-frozen both work. You want a white, firm fish that holds up to slow cooking. Haddock, halibut, or even pollock are solid backups.
-
Melted butter (1/4 cup) – Real butter, please. This isn’t the time for substitutes. Salted is fine—just adjust your added salt later.
-
Olive oil (1 tbsp) – Helps mellow the richness of the butter and adds depth.
-
Lemons (2), thinly sliced – You’ll layer these in like a citrusy little mattress for the cod. They soften into something almost candy-like.
-
Garlic (3 cloves, minced) – Don’t skimp here. Garlic + butter = instant comfort.
-
Chicken broth (1/4 cup) – Keeps everything juicy and flavorful. White wine works too, or veggie broth if you’re going meatless.
-
Fresh parsley (2 tbsp, chopped) – For color and brightness at the end. Dill or thyme also play well here.
-
Salt & pepper – Season to taste, always. Fish needs a little coaxing.
Slow and Steady: The Steps
I promise this won’t feel like work. It’s mostly about layering and letting go.
-
Butter it up – Grease your slow cooker with a little melted butter. Don’t skip this step—clean-up will thank you.
-
Lemon blanket – Lay those thin lemon slices right on the bottom. You want full coverage. This keeps the fish from sticking and infuses everything with sunshine.
-
Lay down the cod – Nestle your fillets on top. Try not to overlap them if you can help it—give them space to do their thing.
-
Make your pour-over magic – Mix the rest of the butter with olive oil, garlic, chicken broth, salt, and pepper. Pour that goodness all over the fish. It might not look like much, but trust—it turns into a dreamy sauce.
-
Cook low and slow – Cover and cook on LOW for about 2 to 3 hours, until the fish flakes easily with a fork. Check it at the 2-hour mark if your slow cooker runs hot.
-
Finish with green – Sprinkle chopped parsley over the top and serve it warm, spooning some of that lemon-butter sauce over everything like a final flourish.
Ways to Make It Your Own
Not everyone cooks the same—and that’s a beautiful thing. Here’s how you can play around:
-
Add a kick – A dash of red pepper flakes in the butter mixture wakes things up.
-
Go Frenchy – Swap parsley for fresh thyme and add a splash of dry white wine.
-
Make it a meal – Toss in baby potatoes and green beans around the fish for a true one-pot wonder.
-
Use what you’ve got – No cod? No problem. Any firm white fish will do just fine.
How to Store, Reheat, and Maybe Sneak a Bite Cold
-
Fridge life – Leftovers will keep in the fridge for up to 2 days. Store with extra sauce in an airtight container.
-
Reheating – Low and slow in a pan works best, with a spoonful of the sauce to keep it moist. Microwave’s okay too, just go gently (no one likes rubbery fish).
-
Freezer? Meh. – Technically possible, but I wouldn’t. The texture just doesn’t hold up well.
One Last Bite
Every time I make this, I swear I can hear the hum of Grandma’s old radio and the creak of her kitchen floorboards. This cod isn’t flashy—it’s not Instagram-worthy or stacked high on a plate—but it’s real, and that’s what makes it special. Just honest food with flavor that hugs you a little.
If you give it a go, drop me a note or tell me how you served it. Mashed potatoes? Crusty sourdough? Wine or sweet tea? I always love hearing what lands on your table.
Until next time—keep your butter soft, your lemons fresh, and your dinners simple (but lovely).