Name: Paula's Coconut Cream Pie
Prep time: 25 min
Cook time: 12 min
Total time: 3 min
Ingredients: 2 pieces premade pie dough rounds; 2 cups whole milk; 13.5 oz unsweetened coconut milk; 7 pieces egg yolks; 1 cup granulated sugar; 1/3 cup cornstarch; 1/2 teaspoon salt; 2 cups sweetened coconut flakes; 1 teaspoon vanilla extract; 1 teaspoon coconut extract; 1/4 cup sweetened coconut flakes, toasted; 2 cups cold heavy whipping cream; 1/3 cup powdered sugar; 1 teaspoon coconut extract

Save This Recipe

We'll email this post to you, so you can come back to it later!

The kind of dessert that hushes a room mid-bite.

You ever make something so simple, so quietly perfect, that you surprise even yourself? That was this pie for me.

A few summers ago, I brought it to a family reunion—you know, the kind with kids doing cannonballs in the pool, aunts gossiping under patio umbrellas, and at least five crockpots plugged in near the garage. I had just enough time that morning to toss this together and pray it’d chill in time. Well, turns out it stole the show. Folks were skipping over peach cobbler and banana pudding for a slice of this creamy, coconutty goodness. I had uncles asking for seconds and my cousin Janet texting me for the recipe before she even left the driveway.

So now I keep this one in my back pocket. It’s one of those dependable, “you’ll never bring leftovers home” pies. And Lord knows, we all need one of those.

Why This Pie Works (Like, Every Time)

Let me shoot straight with you. This pie isn’t fussy, but it tastes like you spent hours making it. Here’s why I keep coming back to it:

Silky coconut custard that sets up like a dream—no weird gelatin or box pudding here.
Real coconut flavor (we’re using flakes and coconut milk and extract, because we’re not playing around).
Make-ahead friendly, so you’re not sweating in the kitchen last minute.
Store-bought crust (because ain’t nobody got time for scratch dough every time).
That topping though—homemade whipped cream with a coconut twist? Oh yes.

What You’ll Need (and What You Can Wiggle Around)

I’m all about using what you’ve got—just like grandma used to. But here’s the lineup for the way I make it:

2 premade pie dough rounds
I roll ’em together for a thicker crust in a 9×13 dish. You could use one crust in a round pie pan if you want more filling-to-crust ratio.
Whole milk + unsweetened coconut milk
Whole milk gives that creamy base, and coconut milk brings the flavor. Don’t swap in skim or light coconut milk—just trust me on this.
7 egg yolks
Yep, seven. It’s rich. It’s right.
Sugar, cornstarch, salt
The usual suspects to sweeten and thicken that lovely custard.
Sweetened coconut flakes
These get stirred into the filling and give the whole thing some texture. Like, actual coconut—not just flavoring.
Vanilla and coconut extract
Don’t skip the coconut extract—it’s what makes the pie sing.
Toasted coconut flakes for the top
Toast ’em yourself in a skillet or the oven for a couple minutes. Watch ’em close—they go from golden to burnt in the blink of an eye.
Whipped topping
Cold heavy cream, powdered sugar, and a kiss of coconut extract. You whip it up right before serving. It’s the soft cloud this pie deserves.

Let’s Make It (It’s Easier Than You Think)

Step 1: Bake the Crust

Preheat your oven to 350°F. Roll out those dough rounds into a rectangle and press them into a 9×13” baking dish. Crimp the edges if you’re feeling fancy. Poke holes in the bottom with a fork (so it doesn’t puff up), and bake for 10–12 minutes until golden and crisp. Let it cool completely.

Tip: Want extra flavor? Brush the crust with a little egg wash before baking for a golden shine.

Step 2: Whisk That Custard

In a heavy-bottomed pot (important—it keeps it from scorching), whisk together your whole milk, coconut milk, egg yolks, sugar, cornstarch, and salt. Put it over medium heat and whisk constantly.

Now listen: it’ll take a little time. You’ll be standing there thinking nothing’s happening… and then all at once, boom—it thickens into this gorgeous, glossy pudding. Don’t let it boil, just let it gently thicken.

Once it looks like soft custard, take it off the heat and stir in your coconut flakes, vanilla, and coconut extract.

Step 3: Chill Time

Spoon that filling right into your cooled crust. Let it sit on the counter for about 10–15 minutes, then cover it and pop it in the fridge for at least 3 hours. Overnight is even better if you can wait that long. (I rarely can.)

Step 4: Whip the Topping

When you’re about ready to serve, whip the cream, powdered sugar, and coconut extract until it holds nice stiff peaks. Spread it right over the cold pie, then sprinkle on that toasted coconut like you’re decorating a cake for a county fair.

Want to Tweak It? Go Right Ahead.

You know what I love? A recipe that can take a little sass and still turn out great. Here are a few fun twists:

Chocolate crust: Swap the dough for a graham cracker or chocolate cookie crust. (Oreos work great.)
Pina colada pie: Fold in some crushed pineapple (drained real well) to the filling.
Mini versions: Use muffin tins and make individual pies. Adorable and perfect for showers or bake sales.
Grown-up version: Add a splash of dark rum to the filling. Just one tablespoon makes it feel real fancy.

Got Leftovers? (Lucky You.)

This pie holds up well in the fridge for a few days, just cover it with plastic wrap. The whipped cream will start to soften after about 3–4 days, but it’s still tasty. I wouldn’t recommend freezing the finished pie (cream doesn’t like that), but you can freeze just the custard filling if you’re prepping ahead. Thaw it in the fridge and give it a good stir before spreading into your crust.

Reheating? Don’t bother. This one’s meant to be served cold, straight from the fridge. That’s part of the charm.

Before You Go…

If you end up making this coconut cream pie—please let me know. I’d love to hear how it turned out, who you shared it with, or if someone snuck a slice before dinner (it happens). Got questions? Drop ‘em in the comments. I’m always around to chat pie.

Now go tie that apron, preheat your oven, and make something sweet today. You deserve it.

Love and coconut dreams,